While I have used many PowerPoint presentations over the course of my student career to deliver a speech or project that was assigned to me, I have always found them extremely boring. However, I also believe that I may not have been using the product correctly or keeping an open mind whenever it comes to it. In an article, written by Julia Keller that I recently found, titled Killing Me Microsoftly with PowerPoint raised some key points that I have never considered before.
This excerpt made some strong arguments about the use of PowerPoint within the classroom setting. Some of the negative aspects included that children of a younger age that are just learning how to think and connect ideas may be limited to the only templates that is provided on the program. One of the references that Keller uses name was Sherry Turkle. Turkle, a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, states, “These technologies are changing the way we think. They change how our kids grow up and how they process information”. So how do we integrate PowerPoint into class for student use so that it effectively helps them to be engaged with the assignment?
Another argument suggested in this article was that PowerPoint does not teach students to make an argument and support it. It rather teaches them to just make a point which discourages conversation and interaction. We just need to relate to them what a strong presentation is designed to do. Whether or not PowerPoint is good or bad determines how it is used and implemented into the instruction.
We need to realize the immense effect that technology has on our students. Neil Postman, a professor at New York University, writes, “Technology is ideology. To be unaware that a technology comes equipped with a program for social change, to maintain that technology is neutral, to make the assumption that technology is always a friend to culture is, at this late hour, stupidly plain and simple”. I think that PowerPoint can be effective for teachers and students as long as it is taught correctly and doesn’t limit the student’s creativity because technology can help support engaged learning through capitalizing on the children’s appeal to it.
Like always I have provided a link to the article that I found below but I also found a funny YouTube video on what not to do with PowerPoint presentations!
I’m not sure if I would use it in the classroom because there is one use of profanity and I’m not sure how it would fly in a High School setting but ENJOY!
Article:
http://www.gbuwizards.com/files/chicago-tribune-julia-keller-05-january-2003.htm
YouTube:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lpvgfmEU2Ck